End U S war in Afghanistan: Can YOUR organization adopt this resolution?
[Friends — Today (December 13, 2009), I proposed to a rabbinic organization of which I’m a member that they adopt this resolution (with a few changes to specify our religious tradition). As set forth here (with whatever changes you think appropriate), could you bring it to your own organization, religious or other? For further discussion on this question, see the section of our website here. We welcome comments as made possible at the end of this essay. With blessings toward shalom, salaam, shantih — peace! — Rabbi Arthur Waskow]
A CALL TO SWIFTLY END THE U.S. WAR IN AFGANISTAN
Whereas, some strands of the great religious and ethical traditions of our planet teach that war is never acceptable, and practically all our traditions, as well as the modern international law that binds all nations, command that war must be used — if at all — only when absolutely necessary in self -defense, and then with extreme care to use only the degree of violence necessary to halt an attacker; and
Whereas, the people and nation of Afghanistan, the abysmally poorest country in the world, pose no danger to the United States; and
Whereas Al Qaeda, once headquartered in Afghanistan, is now dispersed in a many-centered network in a number of countries, with very few operatives still in Afghanistan; and
Whereas, the US government’s policy and military strategy in Afghanistan is to impose a corrupt and illegitimate central government on a society for centuries rooted in local and tribal governance, with a passionate opposition to foreign armies; and
Whereas, the head of the Afghani “national government” has himself said it will be 15 to 20 years before that government and its military are capable of achieving on their own the degree of control desired by the US military over a deeply decentralized tribal society; and
Whereas, the announcement by President Obama that the withdrawal of American troops from Afghanistan would “begin” in August 2011 not only had no date for the completion of withdrawal but has been deeply undercut by subsequent assertions by key US officials and generals that even this “beginning” will depend on conditions as they then exist; and
Whereas, the result of this US military intervention has been many deaths, imprisonments, and tortures of Afghani civilians and therewith increasing rage and hatred toward the United States; and
Whereas, the US war in Afghanistan has brought about the deaths and maimings in body, mind, and soul of thousands of Americans, and the recent decision of the US government to escalate the war will now multiply those deaths and maimings; and
Whereas, the US war in Afghanistan has paralyzed and distorted US foreign policy in other, far more crucial areas of the world; and
Whereas, the commitment of hundreds of billions of dollars to carry on this war will prevent vital investments in efficient railroads, replacement of rotting sewers and water systems, renewal of education, installation of a network of advanced renewable energy sources, green jobs, and other crucial needs of American society —
Therefore, be it resolved that [your organization] calls on the President and Congress of the United States to bring swiftly and safely home all US troops and military, CIA, and similar contract personnel from Afghanistan; to explore the possibility of working with local and tribal leaders and with women’s organizations for bringing grass-roots help to economic development; and to redirect money now planned to support the war to meeting vital domestic American needs.



Comments
3 comments postedOur Ann Arbor organization has endorsed this resolution. We will forward it to the President, Secretary of State, and our members of Congress. We are IDAP - InterDenominational Advocates for Peace. Thanks to Rabbi Waskow for this excellent statement.
I’ve been praying and waiting for clarity on this since President Obama referred to the Just War doctrine at Oslo (Nobel Prize address). Unfortunately, the war he now seeks to escalate in Afghanistan fails the principles of Just War in several important areas of moral and ethical reflection, now held universally by many of the world’s great faiths. It is not easy to oppose a well-meaning President who I believe is truly seeking to pursue ultimate peace in Afghanistan, and is at least trying to apply Just War principles to protecting America from further attack by Al Qaida. But Al Qaida is in Pakistan, and hardly at all in Afghanistan. And every American soldier, or attack “drone” in the region just further inflames a people who have already seen too much of Western Imperialism and “collaterall damage”, no matter how naively well-intentioned our present military actions might be. We need a diplomatic “surge” and economic “peace” offensive, along with a just police force supplied by the Arab League, not another US or NATO-led “invasion”, no matter how well intentioned. Thank you Rabbi Waskow for again taking leadership in this area, and for continuing to hold forth the ultimate ideal of nonviolence—beyond “just war”— which so deeply shaped Gandhi, Dr. King, A.J. Heschel, and even Reinhold Neibuhr (at the end of his life.), who was also quoted by our President at Oslo. I will hope to share the text of this letter with members of my own church (Trinity Episcopal Cathedral, Sacramento), and our own Episcopal Peace Fellowship. Shalom!
I generally agree with Rabbi Waskow’s statement.
I have wanted my church for several years to proclaim itself against the war in Iraq.
I think we need to consider standing on the side of PEACE..
Happy Hanukkah. May your candles burn for a very long time.